Worksheet · Unit 1 · High school
Worksheet: Taking Arguments Apart
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
Use your browser's Print command to print this page. Write your answers on paper; this page doesn't collect your work. Every example here is new: none of them appear in the lesson or the self-guided quiz. There is no answer key on this page, so talk through your answers with a teacher, parent or classmate, and check them against the lesson.
Part A: Argument or not?
For each passage, write argument, explanation or assertion. If it's an argument, underline the conclusion and circle any indicator words.
- "Marcus can't be the one who ate the last slice, for he was at swim practice all evening."
- "Our team lost on Friday because two starters were out sick."
- "Jazz is the greatest kind of music ever made."
- "The school play sold out every night last year, and this year's cast is even bigger. Hence the drama club should add a fourth performance."
Part B: Standard form
Rewrite each argument in standard form: numbered premises, a line, then the conclusion. For number 2, add the hidden premise.
- "Since every member of the debate team must keep a B average, and Jamie is on the debate team, Jamie keeps a B average."
- "Rosa is a vegetarian, so she won't order the pepperoni pizza."
Part C: Valid or invalid?
Write valid or invalid. For each invalid argument, describe a counterexample: a possible case where the premises are true and the conclusion is false. Then name the form if it's one of the four from the lesson.
- If the smoke alarm is beeping, its battery is low. The battery is low. So the alarm is beeping.
- If the pool is open, a lifeguard is on duty. No lifeguard is on duty. So the pool is not open.
- All the violinists in the orchestra can read music. Kai can read music. So Kai is a violinist in the orchestra.
- If a number ends in 0, it is divisible by 5. The number 15 doesn't end in 0. So 15 is not divisible by 5.
- If it's a weekday, the cafeteria serves lunch. Today is a weekday. So the cafeteria serves lunch today.
Part D: Valid and sound, valid but unsound, or invalid?
- All planets in our solar system orbit the Sun. Jupiter is a planet in our solar system. So Jupiter orbits the Sun.
- All metals are liquid at room temperature. Iron is a metal. So iron is liquid at room temperature.
Part E: Strong or weak?
Each argument is inductive. Write strong or weak, and give one reason.
- "I saw two red cars speeding on my street this week, so most people who drive red cars speed."
- "In each of the last 12 school years, the first snow day in our town came after Thanksgiving. So this year's first snow day will probably come after Thanksgiving."
Part F: Question like Socrates
Someone defines a friend this way: "A friend is anyone you spend a lot of time with." Write one counterexample to this definition, and explain in a sentence why it shows the definition fails. Then try writing a better definition, and test it yourself.
Sources
- Argument, premises, conclusions and indicator words: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Argument"
- Validity and soundness: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Validity and Soundness"
- Inductive strength: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Deductive and Inductive Arguments"
Worksheet text is original Jugami work. All the people and situations are made up for practice.
Credits: Art: all drawings are original, hand-coded SVG made for Jugami; the share images are rendered from the same art. Our teacher Socrates is a character inspired by the Athenian philosopher, not a real person speaking.