Skip to content
Jugami
Jugami Logic and Philosophy

Worksheet · Unit 1 · High school

Worksheet: Taking Arguments Apart

Name: ______________________   Date: ____________

Use your browser's Print command to print this page. Write your answers on paper; this page doesn't collect your work. Every example here is new: none of them appear in the lesson or the self-guided quiz. There is no answer key on this page, so talk through your answers with a teacher, parent or classmate, and check them against the lesson.

Part A: Argument or not?

For each passage, write argument, explanation or assertion. If it's an argument, underline the conclusion and circle any indicator words.

  1. "Marcus can't be the one who ate the last slice, for he was at swim practice all evening."
  2. "Our team lost on Friday because two starters were out sick."
  3. "Jazz is the greatest kind of music ever made."
  4. "The school play sold out every night last year, and this year's cast is even bigger. Hence the drama club should add a fourth performance."

Part B: Standard form

Rewrite each argument in standard form: numbered premises, a line, then the conclusion. For number 2, add the hidden premise.

  1. "Since every member of the debate team must keep a B average, and Jamie is on the debate team, Jamie keeps a B average."
  2. "Rosa is a vegetarian, so she won't order the pepperoni pizza."

Part C: Valid or invalid?

Write valid or invalid. For each invalid argument, describe a counterexample: a possible case where the premises are true and the conclusion is false. Then name the form if it's one of the four from the lesson.

  1. If the smoke alarm is beeping, its battery is low. The battery is low. So the alarm is beeping.
  2. If the pool is open, a lifeguard is on duty. No lifeguard is on duty. So the pool is not open.
  3. All the violinists in the orchestra can read music. Kai can read music. So Kai is a violinist in the orchestra.
  4. If a number ends in 0, it is divisible by 5. The number 15 doesn't end in 0. So 15 is not divisible by 5.
  5. If it's a weekday, the cafeteria serves lunch. Today is a weekday. So the cafeteria serves lunch today.

Part D: Valid and sound, valid but unsound, or invalid?

  1. All planets in our solar system orbit the Sun. Jupiter is a planet in our solar system. So Jupiter orbits the Sun.
  2. All metals are liquid at room temperature. Iron is a metal. So iron is liquid at room temperature.

Part E: Strong or weak?

Each argument is inductive. Write strong or weak, and give one reason.

  1. "I saw two red cars speeding on my street this week, so most people who drive red cars speed."
  2. "In each of the last 12 school years, the first snow day in our town came after Thanksgiving. So this year's first snow day will probably come after Thanksgiving."

Part F: Question like Socrates

Someone defines a friend this way: "A friend is anyone you spend a lot of time with." Write one counterexample to this definition, and explain in a sentence why it shows the definition fails. Then try writing a better definition, and test it yourself.

Sources

Worksheet text is original Jugami work. All the people and situations are made up for practice.

Credits: Art: all drawings are original, hand-coded SVG made for Jugami; the share images are rendered from the same art. Our teacher Socrates is a character inspired by the Athenian philosopher, not a real person speaking.