Skip to content
Jugami
Jugami Logic and Philosophy

Logic and Philosophy · Unit 1 · High school

Arguments: Premises, Conclusions and Counterexamples

One good counterexample can sink a whole argument.

In one of Plato's dialogues, two men run into each other outside a court in Athens. One is Socrates, who is about to face a charge of impiety. The other, Euthyphro, is there to prosecute his own father for murder, and he is completely sure he knows what piety is. A few questions later, he isn't so sure.

This unit gives you the tools Socrates used on him, and the ones logicians have added since. You'll learn to spot an argument, pull out its premises and conclusion, write it in standard form, and test it. The star tool is the counterexample: a single case that shows reasoning doesn't hold up.

Diagram: two premise boxes with arrows pointing down to a conclusion box. A third card labeled counterexample cuts the link between them. Premise 1 Premise 2 Conclusion COUNTEREXAMPLE
Original diagram. A counterexample keeps the premises true but makes the conclusion false, breaking the link.

Argument, assertion or explanation?

In everyday talk, an "argument" is a fight. In logic it means something calmer. An argument is a set of claims in which some of them, the premises, are offered as reasons to believe another one, the conclusion.

Not every sentence with a reason in it is an argument. Compare these three:

  • Assertion: "Pineapple belongs on pizza." This is a single claim. No reasons are offered, so there's nothing to test except whether you agree.
  • Explanation: "The field is muddy because it rained all night." Nobody doubts the field is muddy; you can see it. The "because" tells you why it happened, not why to believe it.
  • Argument: "Ms. Lee said the test covers chapter 3, and chapter 3 is all about cells, so the test will be about cells." Here the first two claims are reasons to believe the last one, which you couldn't just see for yourself.

A quick test: ask "Is the speaker trying to convince me that something is true?" If yes, you probably have an argument. If they're telling you why something you already accept happened, it's an explanation.

Premises, conclusions and indicator words

Writers often flag the parts of an argument with indicator words.

Common indicator words
TypeCommon indicatorsWhat comes next
Premise indicatorsbecause, since, for, asa reason
Conclusion indicatorstherefore, thus, hence, sothe claim being supported

Be careful: these words don't always do this job. "I've been awake since six" uses "since" for time, not for a reason. And plenty of arguments use no indicator words at all, so you have to ask which claim the others are supporting.

The conclusion isn't always last, either. In "We should leave now, since the movie starts in ten minutes," the conclusion ("we should leave now") comes first.

Standard form

Real arguments come tangled up in conversation. To test one, logicians rewrite it in standard form: number each premise, draw a line, and put the conclusion underneath.

Take this: "Ms. Ortiz said anyone who turns in the permission slip can go on the museum trip. I turned mine in this morning. So I can go on the trip."

  1. Anyone who turns in the permission slip can go on the museum trip.
  2. I turned in my permission slip.

Conclusion: I can go on the museum trip.

Notice what got cut: "Ms. Ortiz said" and "this morning" don't change the reasoning. Standard form keeps only the claims doing the work.

Hidden premises

Sometimes a premise is left unsaid. "Jordan is a lifeguard, so Jordan knows CPR" only works if you add an unstated premise: "All lifeguards know CPR." Writing hidden premises down lets you check whether they're actually true.

Valid is not the same as true

A deductive argument tries to guarantee its conclusion. Logicians judge it in two steps.

  • Valid: it is impossible for all the premises to be true while the conclusion is false. If the premises were true, the conclusion would have to be true too.
  • Sound: valid and every premise is actually true.

Validity is about the link between premises and conclusion, not about whether the sentences are true. That surprises most people. Look at these four:

Four arguments compared for validity and soundness
ArgumentValid?Premises true?Verdict
All squares have four sides. This tile is a square. So this tile has four sides.YesYes (if the tile really is square)Sound
All teenagers can fly. Maria is a teenager. So Maria can fly.YesNo: teenagers can't flyValid but unsound
Every U.S. president has been at least 35 years old. Abraham Lincoln was at least 35. So Lincoln was a U.S. president.NoYes, and the conclusion is true tooInvalid (true sentences, bad link)
Some students play chess. So every student plays chess.NoYesInvalid

The Lincoln argument is the sneaky one. Every sentence in it is true, yet the reasoning is broken. Being at least 35 doesn't make anyone president. The next section shows how to prove that.

Why it matters

A sound argument always has a true conclusion. But a bad argument can still have a true conclusion by luck. So showing someone's argument is invalid doesn't prove their conclusion is false. It only shows their reasons don't prove it.

The counterexample method

To show an argument is invalid, you don't have to argue for hours. You need one counterexample: a possible situation in which every premise is true and the conclusion is false. If such a situation can exist, the premises don't guarantee the conclusion.

Three steps

  1. Put it in standard form. Know exactly what the premises and conclusion say.
  2. Keep the premises true. Imagine a case, real or made up but possible, where every premise holds.
  3. Make the conclusion false in that same case. If you can, you've found a counterexample, and the argument is invalid.

Try it on the Lincoln argument. Picture any 40-year-old who has never been president. "Every U.S. president has been at least 35" is still true, and this person is at least 35, but they aren't a president. Counterexample found.

The same-form trick

Another way: keep the argument's form, but swap in new content so the premises are obviously true and the conclusion is obviously false.

  1. Every U.S. president has been at least 35 years old.
  2. Socrates was at least 35 (he lived to about 70).

Conclusion: Socrates was a U.S. president.

Same pattern, true premises, ridiculous conclusion. Since validity depends on form, any argument with this pattern is invalid.

What if you can't find a counterexample? That's evidence the argument may be valid, but not proof. You might just not have imagined the right case yet. Logicians use formal methods, such as truth tables, to prove validity.

Counterexamples to general claims

Counterexamples also knock down sweeping claims. "All students are lazy" falls to a single hardworking student. Any claim about all of something, including a definition, can be tested this way. Socrates was famous for it, as you'll see below.

Four forms to know

Many everyday arguments use a conditional, an "if … then …" claim. The "if" part is the antecedent; the "then" part is the consequent. Here are two valid forms and two invalid look-alikes.

Two valid and two invalid conditional forms
FormPatternExampleVerdict
Modus ponens (affirming the antecedent)If P, then Q. P. So Q.If the bell rings, class is over. The bell rang. So class is over.Valid
Modus tollens (denying the consequent)If P, then Q. Not Q. So not P.If it's a school day, the buses run. The buses aren't running. So it isn't a school day.Valid
Affirming the consequentIf P, then Q. Q. So P.If Ava is in the marching band, she has practice on Tuesdays. Ava has practice on Tuesdays. So Ava is in the marching band.Invalid. Counterexample: Ava is on the soccer team, which also practices on Tuesdays.
Denying the antecedentIf P, then Q. Not P. So not Q.If you live in Chicago, you live in Illinois. Sam doesn't live in Chicago. So Sam doesn't live in Illinois.Invalid. Counterexample: Sam lives in Springfield, Illinois.

The invalid forms are called formal fallacies: errors in the pattern itself, whatever the topic. They're tempting because they look like the valid forms. The fix is to remember that a conditional only works in one direction. "If P, then Q" doesn't say Q can only happen when P does.

How old are these patterns?

Logic as an organized subject begins with Aristotle in the 300s BCE. A century later, the Stoic philosopher Chrysippus built a logic of whole statements. Its first two basic argument types match modus ponens and modus tollens.

Mini-game: valid or invalid? (about 3 min)

Read each argument in standard form and decide: valid or invalid? After you answer, you'll see why, including a counterexample for every invalid one. Use Tab and Enter, or tap the buttons.

Strong, weak and probably true

Not every argument tries for a guarantee. An inductive argument claims only that its premises make the conclusion likely. So we don't call it valid or invalid. We call it strong or weak.

  • Strong: "The last 30 times the robotics club held a bake sale, it sold out by noon. So Saturday's bake sale will probably sell out by noon." Lots of similar past cases make the conclusion likely, though rain or a smaller batch could still prove it wrong.
  • Weak: "My cousin's phone broke, so this brand of phone must be fragile." One case is far too little to support a claim about a whole brand.

A strong inductive argument with true premises is called cogent. Science, history and everyday decisions run on inductive arguments, so learning to tell strong from weak matters as much as spotting validity.

Socrates and the art of questioning

Your teacher on this course is a character inspired by Socrates. The real Socrates left no writings, so this page doesn't put words in his mouth. The quotes below come from Plato's dialogues, in Benjamin Jowett's translation.

Who was he?

Socrates lived in Athens from about 469 to 399 BCE. He wrote nothing. What we know comes mainly from other people, especially his student Plato, the writer Xenophon and the comic playwright Aristophanes, and their pictures don't always agree. Scholars call this puzzle "the Socratic problem." In 399 BCE, at about age 70, he was put on trial, convicted on charges of impiety and corrupting the young, and put to death.

The elenchus

In Plato's dialogues, Socrates' signature move is the elenchus (ih-LENK-us), a Greek word for cross-examination or refutation. He usually asks a "What is it?" question, like "What is courage?" or "What is piety?" Then he questions the person's answer, drawing out other things they believe, until the answer clashes with those beliefs.

Here's how it goes in the Euthyphro. Asked what piety is, Euthyphro offers a definition:

"Piety, then, is that which is dear to the gods, and impiety is that which is not dear to them."

Plato, Euthyphro 7a, trans. Benjamin Jowett

Socrates doesn't simply disagree. He gets Euthyphro to agree to things Euthyphro already believes: that the gods, in the Greek stories, quarrel, and that they quarrel over what is just and unjust. Then:

SOCRATES: "Then the same things are hated by the gods and loved by the gods, and are both hateful and dear to them?"
EUTHYPHRO: "True."
SOCRATES: "And upon this view the same things, Euthyphro, will be pious and also impious?"
EUTHYPHRO: "So I should suppose."

Plato, Euthyphro 7e–8a, trans. Benjamin Jowett

That's a counterexample in action. A definition is a claim about every pious act. If one act can be dear to some gods and hateful to others, then by Euthyphro's own definition it is both pious and impious, which is the opposite of what a definition should do. Euthyphro tries new definitions, and Socrates tests each one. The dialogue ends with Euthyphro saying he's in a hurry and leaving, with no definition left standing.

Later in the same dialogue, Socrates asks a question philosophers still argue about, now called the Euthyphro dilemma: "whether the pious or holy is beloved by the gods because it is holy, or holy because it is beloved of the gods" (10a, Jowett).

What did the questioning prove?

Scholars disagree. The elenchus shows that a person's beliefs don't fit together. But it doesn't say which belief is the false one. Maybe the definition is wrong, or maybe one of the other premises is. The philosopher Gregory Vlastos called this "the problem of the Socratic elenchus," and it's still debated.

In Plato's Apology, his version of Socrates' defense speech at the trial, Socrates explains why he kept questioning people. He says that talking every day about virtue, and examining himself and others, is the greatest good for a person, and that "the unexamined life is not worth living" (38a, Jowett).

Practice problems

The worksheet has all-new arguments to sort, put in standard form, test with counterexamples and judge. None of them appear on this page or in the self-guided quiz, so it's a real check of what you've learned.

Self-guided quiz

Nine questions. Choose an answer to see feedback right away. Your first pick locks in and is the one that counts. Every answer explains why it's right or wrong and which section to reread.

1. Which of these is an argument, not just an assertion or an explanation?

2. "Since the library closes at 5 and it's already 5:30, we can't return the book today." What is the conclusion?

3. When is a deductive argument valid?

4. "If someone is a sophomore here, they are a student at this school. Lena is a student at this school. So Lena is a sophomore." Which fact would be a counterexample showing this reasoning is invalid?

5. "All fish can fly. A salmon is a fish. So a salmon can fly." What is the best verdict?

6. "If the game is sold out, we can't buy tickets at the door. We can buy tickets at the door. So the game isn't sold out." Which form is this?

7. "If it snows, school closes. It didn't snow. So school didn't close." What is the problem?

8. "Every one of the 40 apples Jamal checked from this crate was ripe, so the next apple from it will probably be ripe." How should we describe this?

9. In Plato's Euthyphro, how does Socrates challenge the definition "piety is what is dear to the gods"?

Score: 0 of 9

Talk about it

  • Showing an argument is invalid doesn't show its conclusion is false. Why do people so often act as if it does?
  • Socrates' questions left Euthyphro without an answer. Is it useful to learn that you don't know something, even if you don't get a better answer?
  • Think of an ad or a social media post that uses affirming the consequent. Why might that pattern persuade people?
  • Inductive arguments never guarantee their conclusions. How much evidence should it take before you act on one?

Sources

Lesson text, examples, diagrams and the mini-game are original Jugami work. Quotations are from Benjamin Jowett's public-domain translations of Plato on Project Gutenberg; section numbers (7a, 7e–8a, 10a, 38a) are the standard Stephanus numbers, which you can check in the Perseus Digital Library links above.

Credits: Art: all drawings are original, hand-coded SVG made for Jugami; the share images are rendered from the same art. Our teacher Socrates is a character inspired by the Athenian philosopher, not a real person speaking.