Some writing tells you what happened. Some writing tells you what to think about it. Both belong in a newspaper, as long as readers can tell which is which.
Your assignment
In Unit 1 you sorted single sentences into facts and opinions. In Unit 2 you gathered information from people. Now you will zoom out to whole pieces of writing. Is this article a news report or opinion journalism? And where did its information come from?
By the end of this unit, you should be able to tell news from opinion by its label and its language, explain why opinion pieces still need accurate facts, and check a source before you trust it or use it.
1. Two jobs in one newspaper
Most news organizations do two different jobs.
News reporting tells readers what happened, using facts the reporter has checked. The reporter does not say what they personally think. If a news story includes an opinion, it belongs to a person who was interviewed, and the story says who. (You practiced that kind of attribution in Unit 2.)
Opinion journalism argues for a point of view. The writer chooses facts and arranges them to make a case. Stony Brook University’s Center for News Literacy describes opinion journalists as writers who select key facts and build an argument.
Both jobs are useful. News gives you the facts. Opinion pieces can show you arguments you might not have thought of. The problem comes when readers cannot tell which job a piece is doing. The Society of Professional Journalists (SPJ) Code of Ethics asks journalists to label opinion journalism and news analysis for exactly this reason.
Did you know? Even adults find this hard. In a 2018 Pew Research Center survey of about 5,000 U.S. adults, only 26% correctly sorted all five factual statements they were shown, and 35% correctly sorted all five opinion statements.
2. Read the label first
The fastest clue is often printed right above the headline. Responsible news organizations label their opinion work. Here are labels you may see:
Editorial
The news organization’s own official position on an issue. Editorials are opinion.
Column
A piece in which a named writer gives their own views.
Op-ed or guest essay
An opinion piece, often by someone from outside the newsroom. The name comes from “opposite the editorial page,” where these pieces once ran in print. In 2021, The New York Times began calling them “guest essays.”
Review
A writer’s judgment of a movie, book, game, meal or show.
News analysis
A piece that interprets the news instead of only reporting it. The SPJ Code asks newsrooms to label news analysis, and the Stony Brook center lists it among opinion labels.
One more label matters a lot: Sponsored or Paid post. That means someone paid to place the content. It is advertising, not news. The SPJ Code asks newsrooms to keep news separate from advertising and to label sponsored content prominently.
Labels can be small, and on TV or video they may flash by quickly. Look for them on purpose.
3. Clues inside the writing
Sometimes there is no label, or you miss it. Then read the language. The Stony Brook center lists signals that often point to opinion:
Exaggeration and superlatives: “the worst decision ever,” “the best club in school.”
Sarcasm or mocking: a tone that pokes fun at a person or idea.
A news report sounds different. It sticks to what can be checked, it credits each claim to a source, and it lets quoted people supply the opinions.
The tricky middle
Some statements are hard to sort. Pew’s researchers called them borderline. They may be based on evidence, but they are too vague to prove, or they predict the future. “The new schedule will help students learn more” is a prediction. Nobody can prove it yet. When you meet a statement like this, ask what evidence could settle it, and when.
4. Opinion still needs facts
An opinion piece is not a place to make things up. The News Literacy Project says good opinion pieces include verifiable facts and evidence, and the best ones use facts and clear arguments to explain why readers should agree. The SPJ Code asks for “facts and good-faith arguments.”
So check the facts inside an opinion piece the same way you would check a news story. A writer is free to argue that the library should stay open longer. The writer is not free to invent how many students use it.
Watch for writing that only pretends to be fair opinion. The News Literacy Project describes propaganda as one-sided material that plays on fears, twists facts and often includes falsehoods.
5. Check the source
A source is wherever information comes from: a person, a document, a website or a video. Researchers at Stanford watched professional fact-checkers and found they asked three questions about any source:
Who is behind the information? Who made it, and why?
What is the evidence? Does it show proof, or just make a claim?
What do other sources say? Do trustworthy sources agree?
Read sideways
When fact-checkers landed on an unfamiliar website, they did not spend long reading it top to bottom. They quickly opened new tabs and searched for what other sources said about the site. The researchers call this lateral reading, which means reading sideways.
The same researchers found that students often judged a site by its looks: a .org address, no ads, a contact page. Those features are easy to fake, so they prove very little.
Go to the original
The SPJ Code tells journalists to use original sources whenever possible. Historians use similar words. The Library of Congress describes primary sources as original materials created at the time, and secondary sources as accounts that retell or interpret events later.
For a reporter, that means tracing a claim back to where it started. Did the board really vote? Read the meeting record. Did a study really find that? Find the study. Ask any person who gives you information: “How do you know?” Were they there, or did they hear it from someone else?
Finally, tell your readers where your information came from. The SPJ Code says the public deserves enough detail to judge how reliable a source is and what its motives might be.
6. Newsroom lab: one event, two jobs
Fictional teaching example: Harbor View Middle School, The Harbor View Herald and everyone in them are invented for this lesson.
The Harbor View Herald covered one change in two different ways. Read both, then look at the editor’s notes.
News
Library to stay open later two days a week
Starting Monday, Jan. 11, the Harbor View library will stay open until 5 p.m. on Tuesdays and Thursdays, according to an announcement from the principal’s office.
Librarian Priya Nair said the change was made because the library’s after-school sign-in sheet showed 41 students on one recent Tuesday.
“Some students told me they need a quiet place to finish homework,” Nair said.
Editorial · The Herald’s view
Two late days are good. Five would be better.
The library’s new hours are a welcome start. On one recent Tuesday, 41 students signed in after school, according to the library’s sign-in sheet. That shows real demand.
We think the library should stay open until 5 p.m. every school day. Students need a quiet place to work all week, not just on Tuesdays and Thursdays.
Read it like an editor
The news story has no “we think.” The one opinion in it belongs to a named source and is in quotation marks.
The editorial is labeled and argues for a change, but it uses the same checked fact: 41 students, from the sign-in sheet.
Both pieces name where the number came from, so readers can judge it.
A claim to check
Then a flyer appears in the hallway: “Nobody uses the library after school!” It has no name on it and no evidence. Run the three questions.
Who is behind it? Unknown. That alone is a warning.
What is the evidence? None is given.
What do other sources say? The library’s sign-in sheet, an original record, shows 41 students on one Tuesday.
The Herald should not repeat the flyer’s claim as if it were true. A reporter could ask who made it and why. If the answer is newsworthy, the story would report the claim along with the sign-in record that contradicts it.
Find a news website or your school paper. Write down three labels you see above headlines, such as Opinion, Review or Sponsored. What does each one tell a reader?
Write two sentences about a school event: one a factual statement someone could check, and one an opinion. Underline the word that makes the second one an opinion.
Rewrite the Herald editorial’s second paragraph as one neutral news sentence. What did you have to remove?
Think of something you heard recently that surprised you. Answer the three source-checking questions about it.
Talk about it
Should a school paper publish editorials at all? Some people say a student paper should only report. Others say editorials teach students to argue with evidence. What would you decide, and what rules would you set? There is no single right answer.
Try the interactive version at jugami.com/journalism/news-and-opinion/
Self-guided quiz: news, opinion or neither?
Choose one answer in each question and select “Check answers.” Every choice has its own explanation. The score counts your current answers; “Try again” clears the attempt and shuffles the questions and choices. Nothing is sent or saved.
Before you publish
Is the piece clearly labeled as news or opinion?
In a news story, does every opinion belong to a named source?
In an opinion piece, is every fact accurate and checkable?
Did you trace each important claim to its original source?
Can readers see where your information came from?
Sources
Guidance on this page is written in original words, based on the sources below. The survey figures are from the Pew Research Center’s 2018 report.
Colophon: original news-and-opinion card art created for Jugami. Harbor View Middle School, The Harbor View Herald, Priya Nair, the flyer and all quiz scenarios are fictional teaching materials, not reported news. No real person is quoted on this page.