Some of the oldest promises in American law are still being kept, argued over, and enforced.
Every November 11, people gather in Canandaigua, New York, to mark a treaty signed there in 1794 between the United States and the Six Nations of the Haudenosaunee. Under that treaty, the United States still provides cloth every year. That small, stubborn fact opens a big question: what does it mean for a Native nation to be a nation?
On this page you will learn what tribal sovereignty is, read the parts of the Constitution and the court cases that shape it, follow three treaties that are still law, and meet four Native nations governing themselves today. Then test yourself with a self-guided quiz.
What sovereignty means
Sovereignty is a people’s authority to govern themselves: to make their own laws, run their own courts, decide who belongs, and deal with other governments as equals.
Tribal sovereignty is that authority held by a Native nation. The key word is inherent. Native nations governed themselves long before the United States existed. U.S. law recognizes that power. It did not create it.
The Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), the federal agency that works most closely with tribes, sums up the principle the Supreme Court set out in the 1830s:
“That tribes possess a nationhood status and retain inherent powers of self-government.”
Bureau of Indian Affairs, Frequently Asked Questions
Notice the word retain. A government keeps what it already had. That is why lawyers say the United States and a tribe have a government-to-government relationship, not a ruler-to-subject one.
Sovereignty is not one-size-fits-all. There are 575 federally recognized tribes, and each has its own history, language, laws and way of governing. “Native Americans” are not one culture, so on this page we name nations, and we use the names they use for themselves.
Treaty
A formal agreement between sovereign nations. In U.S. law it is made by the President and approved by the Senate.
Ratification
The step that makes a signed treaty binding. For the United States, the Senate gives “advice and consent,” then the President ratifies and proclaims it.
Reservation
Land reserved for a Native nation by treaty, by act of Congress, or by executive order. A tribe governs there alongside federal law.
Jurisdiction
The legal power to make and enforce laws over certain people, places or cases. Which court can hear a case is a question of jurisdiction.
Three clauses that matter
The U.S. Constitution names tribes only a few times, but three clauses do a lot of work. The quotations below are from the National Archives transcription.
“To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes;”
Article I, Section 8, the Indian Commerce Clause
Why it matters: Tribes sit in the same sentence as foreign nations and the states. Dealings with tribes belong to Congress, not to individual states.
“He shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur;”
Article II, Section 2, the Treaty Clause
Why it matters: A treaty is a serious act. Signing is not enough; two-thirds of the Senators present must agree before the United States is bound.
“…all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby…”
Article VI, the Supremacy Clause
Why it matters: A ratified treaty has the same rank as a federal law: below the Constitution, but above any state law. State judges must follow it, even over their own state’s laws. Congress can change a treaty only by saying so clearly.
Two cases, two years
In the early 1830s, Georgia tried to enforce its own laws inside the Cherokee Nation. The Cherokee Nation sued, and a missionary jailed by Georgia appealed. The two decisions, written by Chief Justice John Marshall, became foundations of federal Indian law. Courts still cite both.
Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831)
The Cherokee Nation sued Georgia directly in the Supreme Court as a “foreign state.” The Court said it could not hear the case that way, because a tribe was not a foreign nation in the Constitution’s sense. But Marshall did not call the Cherokee Nation a mere group of people, either:
“They may, more correctly, perhaps, be denominated domestic dependent nations.”
Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. 1 (1831), opinion of Chief Justice Marshall
Close reading: Each word pulls in a different direction. Nations admits the Cherokee are a political people with a government. Domestic places them inside U.S. borders. Dependent claims they rely on the United States. The hedge “more correctly, perhaps” shows Marshall inventing a new category on the spot.
Marshall added that the tribes’ “relation to the United States resembles that of a ward to his guardian.” Think about what that comparison implies about who makes the decisions. The BIA traces the federal government’s duty toward tribes, now called the trust responsibility, back to this same case.
Worcester v. Georgia (1832)
Georgia arrested Samuel Worcester, a missionary living in the Cherokee Nation, for breaking a state law that required a state license to live there. The Supreme Court overturned his conviction.
“The Cherokee nation, then, is a distinct community occupying its own territory, with boundaries accurately described, in which the laws of Georgia can have no force, and which the citizens of Georgia have no right to enter, but with the assent of the Cherokees themselves, or in conformity with treaties, and with the acts of congress.”
Worcester v. Georgia, 31 U.S. 515 (1832), opinion of Chief Justice Marshall
Close reading: The sentence draws a border. Inside it, a state’s laws stop. Only the Cherokee themselves, treaties, and Congress can open it. Notice who is missing from that list: Georgia.
Worcester did not stop the federal removal policy that followed, a history studied in other courses. Its legal idea has had a long and contested life of its own.
In 2022, in Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta, a five-justice majority wrote that “the Worcester-era understanding of Indian country as separate from the State was abandoned later in the 1800s.” Today a state’s power in Indian country can still be blocked by federal law, or when it would unlawfully infringe on tribal self-government. The four dissenting justices defended Worcester. The argument is not over.
Treaties as living law
The United States made treaties with Native nations from its earliest years until 1871. Many treaty promises were broken. Many are still in force, and courts still read them line by line. Here are three, from three regions, with their dates kept straight. A treaty’s signing date and its ratification date are different events, sometimes years apart.
Canandaigua, 1794: Haudenosaunee and the United States
The Six Nations of the Haudenosaunee are the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca and Tuscarora. Their leaders and U.S. agent Timothy Pickering signed this treaty, sometimes called the Pickering Treaty, at Canandaigua, New York.
November 11, 1794: signed at Canandaigua.
January 21, 1795: proclaimed by President George Washington after the Senate’s consent.
“…four thousand five hundred dollars; which shall be expended yearly forever, in purchasing clothing, domestic animals, implements of husbandry and other utensils suited to their circumstances…”
Treaty of Canandaigua, Article VI (Avalon Project text)
Why it matters: “Yearly forever” is not a figure of speech. The United States still provides $4,500 a year for the distribution of treaty cloth. The Oneida Indian Nation calls the cloth an important symbol of its continuing government-to-government relationship with the United States. Each November 11, the treaty is commemorated in Canandaigua.
Fort Laramie, 1868: the Great Sioux Reservation
This treaty was made with Lakota and Dakota bands of the Sioux Nation, including the Oglala, Brulé, Hunkpapa, Yanktonai and Santee, and with the Arapaho. It set apart the Great Sioux Reservation, including the Black Hills, for the bands named in it.
April 29, 1868: first signatures at Fort Laramie; other bands signed later that year, into November.
February 16, 1869: the Senate advised and consented to ratification.
February 24, 1869: President Andrew Johnson proclaimed the treaty.
“…set apart for the absolute and undisturbed use and occupation of the Indians herein named…”
Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, Article II
Article XII added a safeguard: no cession of reservation land would be valid unless signed by at least three-fourths of the adult men. In 1876 a federal commission presented an “agreement” to give up the Black Hills that only about 10 percent of adult Sioux men signed, and in 1877 Congress passed an act taking the Black Hills anyway.
The Sioux nations fought this in court for generations. In United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians (1980), the Supreme Court held that the 1877 act was a taking of property that required just compensation, with interest from 1877. The Sioux nations have refused the money and continue to seek the return of the land itself.
The treaty is no museum piece. The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, whose people are Dakota and Lakota, publishes it on its official website today.
Point Elliott, 1855: Puget Sound
Washington Territory governor Isaac Stevens made this treaty with tribes and bands around Puget Sound. The Tulalip Tribes, whom you will meet below, are successors to several of them.
January 22, 1855: concluded at Point Elliott (Mukilteo).
March 8, 1859: ratified by the Senate, more than four years later.
April 11, 1859: proclaimed by the President.
“The right of taking fish at usual and accustomed grounds and stations is further secured to said Indians in common with all citizens of the Territory…”
Treaty of Point Elliott, Article 5
Why it matters: In United States v. Washington (decided February 12, 1974), Judge George Boldt read “in common with” to mean sharing: treaty tribes could take up to half of the harvestable fish, and tribes and the state would manage the fishery together. In 1979 the Supreme Court upheld the core of that reading.
Why old treaties still bind
In 1871 Congress stopped making treaties with tribes. But it was careful not to cancel the old ones:
“…but no obligation of any treaty lawfully made and ratified with any such Indian nation or tribe prior to March 3, 1871, shall be hereby invalidated or impaired.”
25 U.S. Code § 71
Courts also follow a firm rule about promises that are still on the books. As the Supreme Court put it in 2020: “If Congress wishes to withdraw its promises, it must say so.” You will see that rule decide a major case below.
Meet four nations
Sovereignty is easiest to understand in action. These four nations sit in four different regions. Each profile uses the nation’s official name and draws on its official website.
Navajo Nation
The people call themselves Diné; their homeland is Diné Bikéyah.
Where
Arizona, New Mexico and Utah, over 27,000 square miles
Capital
Window Rock, Arizona
Government
Three branches; a 24-member Navajo Nation Council representing 110 chapters
Courts
Trial courts, the Navajo Nation Supreme Court, and a Peacemaking Program
In 1968 the Nation founded Navajo Community College, now Diné College, the first tribally controlled college in the United States. Council delegates often speak Navajo during sessions.
Cherokee Nation
Headquartered in Tahlequah, Oklahoma; the largest of three federally recognized Cherokee tribes.
Where
A 14-county reservation in northeastern Oklahoma
Government
A written constitution; a Principal Chief; a 17-member Tribal Council
Courts
District Court and the Cherokee Nation Supreme Court
Language
ᏣᎳᎩ ᏧᎾᏕᎶᏆᏍᏗ (Tsalagi Tsunadeloquasdi), an immersion school taught in Cherokee
The Nation that brought the 1831 case governs today. Its businesses span gaming and manufacturing, and together with the tribal government they employ about 11,000 people in northeastern Oklahoma. The other two Cherokee tribes are the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians and the United Keetoowah Band.
Muscogee (Creek) Nation
Its language is Mvskoke; the Nation also supports the Euchee language.
Where
Eastern Oklahoma; capital at Okmulgee
Government
Three branches; a Principal Chief; a 16-member National Council
Courts
District Court and the Muscogee Nation Supreme Court
In McGirt v. Oklahoma (decided July 9, 2020), the Supreme Court held that the Muscogee (Creek) Reservation was never disestablished by Congress and remains “Indian country” for federal criminal law. Justice Gorsuch wrote: “Because Congress has not said otherwise, we hold the government to its word.”
Tulalip Tribes
Successors to the Snohomish, Snoqualmie, Skykomish and other allied tribes and bands of the Treaty of Point Elliott.
Where
The Tulalip Reservation, about 22,000 acres north of Everett, Washington
Government
A tribal constitution and an elected Board of Directors
The name Tulalip comes from the Salish word for the bay on the reservation. In 2014 the Tribes were among the first to use a new federal law letting tribal courts prosecute some non-Native people for domestic violence.
Who has jurisdiction?
When a crime happens in Indian country, the first question is often which government can prosecute. The answer can depend on who was involved, where it happened, and what the crime was. Three decisions show how the pieces move.
1978: Oliphant
In Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe, the Supreme Court held that tribal courts do not have inherent criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians unless Congress authorizes it.
In 2013, Congress did authorize it for certain domestic violence crimes. The Tulalip Tribes began using that power in February 2014.
2020: McGirt
Because the Muscogee (Creek) Reservation still exists, major crimes by Native people there are prosecuted by the federal government, not by Oklahoma. The ruling was about criminal law. It did not give the Nation ownership of all land within its borders.
2022: Castro-Huerta
In Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta (decided June 29, 2022), the Court held that “the Federal Government and the State have concurrent jurisdiction to prosecute crimes committed by non-Indians against Indians in Indian country.” Oklahoma’s own criminal appeals court had said that power belonged only to the federal government.
Read together, these cases show that sovereignty is not frozen. Congress, courts and tribes keep adjusting where one government’s power ends and another’s begins.
Self-determination today
For long stretches, federal policy tried to manage tribes from Washington or to end the relationship altogether. A turn came in the 1970s. On January 4, 1975, President Gerald Ford signed the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (Public Law 93-638). It lets tribes contract to run programs, such as schools, that federal agencies had run for them.
“My Administration is committed to furthering the self-determination of Indian communities without terminating the special relationships between the Federal Government and the Indian people.”
President Gerald R. Ford, signing statement, January 4, 1975 (American Presidency Project)
Why it matters: “Without terminating” is pointed. An earlier federal policy, called termination, had ended the federal relationship with some tribes. Self-determination meant tribes running their own affairs while the United States kept its promises.
The trust responsibility
The trust responsibility is the federal government’s legally enforceable duty to protect tribal treaty rights, lands, assets and resources. The BIA describes it with words from a 1942 Supreme Court case: the United States “has charged itself with moral obligations of the highest responsibility and trust” toward tribes.
Who is recognized?
Federal recognition means the United States acknowledges a tribe as a government with a government-to-government relationship, eligible for federal services. A group can be recognized in three ways: by an act of Congress, by the Interior Department’s acknowledgment process, or by a federal court decision. A state can recognize a tribe for its own purposes, but it cannot grant federal recognition.
The BIA’s list published January 30, 2026 counts 575 federally recognized tribes. The newest is the Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina, recognized by Congress in a law enacted December 18, 2025.
Nations building their own institutions
Self-determination shows up in everyday institutions: Diné College and the College of the Muscogee Nation, Cherokee-language immersion classrooms, tribal courts and police, and tribal businesses. Some tribes run casinos, but gaming is only one piece. Nations also run health systems, schools, housing, farms, manufacturing and more.
Talk About It
Is a treaty more like a contract, a law, or a promise between nations? Can it be all three at once?
Marshall called tribes “domestic dependent nations.” Which of those three words does the most work, and whom does that wording serve?
The Sioux nations have turned down compensation for the Black Hills. What does that choice say about the difference between land and money?
McGirt says that if Congress wants to break a promise, it must say so. Should courts or Congress have the last word on treaty rights? Why?
Whose homelands is your school on? Find that nation’s official website. How does it describe its own government today?
U.S. Statutes at Large, 7 Stat. 44 (Canandaigua: signed November 11, 1794; proclaimed January 21, 1795) and 15 Stat. 635 (Fort Laramie: ratification advised February 16, 1869; proclaimed February 24, 1869).
Washington Governor’s Office of Indian Affairs, Treaty of Point Elliott, 1855; 12 Stat. 927 (concluded January 22, 1855; ratified March 8, 1859; proclaimed April 11, 1859).