Unit 3 · Fractions and Shapes · Grades 1–3
Comparing Equal Shares
Which share is bigger?
You already know how to name halves, thirds and fourths. You also know circles, squares, triangles and hexagons. Now let's put them together and compare shares. Is one half more than one third? Can two shares that look different be the same size?
The big idea: When wholes are the same size, more equal shares make smaller shares. Equal shares can look different and still be the same size. And we only compare shares fairly when the wholes match.
2. Line them up: 1/2, 1/3, 1/4
For wholes that are the same size, here is the order from biggest share to smallest share:
1/2 is bigger than 1/3. 1/3 is bigger than 1/4.
Watch out for a trick! The 4 in 1/4 is a bigger number than the 2 in 1/2. But 1/4 is the smaller share. The bottom number tells how many shares the whole is cut into. More shares means smaller shares.
Math signs for comparing
In grade 3, kids learn to write comparisons with math signs.
| Sign | Say it like this | Example |
|---|---|---|
| > | is bigger than | 1/2 > 1/4 |
| < | is smaller than | 1/4 < 1/2 |
| = | is the same size as | 1/3 = 1/3 |
A tip: the open side of > or < faces the bigger share, like a hungry mouth.
3. Same size, different look
Here are three rectangles. They are all the same size, and each one is cut into 4 equal shares. But each one is cut a different way.
One shaded share is a tall strip. One is a small box. One is a triangle. They do not look alike. But each one is 1 fourth of the same rectangle, so each covers the same amount of space.
Pause and think: Are the triangle shares all the same shape? No! The top and bottom triangles are wider than the two side triangles. But all four cover the same amount of space. So they are still equal shares.
4. Fair compare: same-size wholes
Here is one more rule. To compare shares fairly, the wholes must be the same size.
Both shaded shares are one half. But half of the big square is much bigger than half of the small square. A half is only as big as its whole.
So when someone says “one half is bigger than one third,” they mean halves and thirds of the same-size whole.
5. Try it: the cover test
You need two paper squares that are the same size, scissors and a crayon. Ask a grown-up to help with the scissors.
- Fold the first square straight down the middle. Cut on the fold. You have two rectangle halves.
- Fold the second square from corner to corner. Cut on the fold. You have two triangle halves.
- Lay one triangle on one rectangle. Match the square corner of the triangle with a corner of the rectangle, and lay a triangle edge along the long side of the rectangle. A small corner of the triangle sticks out.
- Snip off the part that sticks out. Does it fill the empty gap exactly? It should! So the triangle half and the rectangle half cover the same amount.
Grown-up note
This unit follows the Common Core geometry and fraction standards. Grade 1 (1.G.3) notes that cutting into more equal shares creates smaller shares. Grade 2 (2.G.3) adds that equal shares of identical wholes need not have the same shape. Grade 3 (3.NF.3d) compares fractions with the same numerator, such as 1/2 and 1/4, by reasoning about their size. It also says comparisons are valid only when both fractions refer to the same whole, and records results with >, = and <. In the cover test, the corner that sticks out is the same size and shape as the gap, so it fits exactly. That is why the two halves match.
6. Practice problems
Print the Comparing Equal Shares worksheet (PDF)
- Draw two rectangles that are the same size. Shade 1 half of one and 1 third of the other. Which shaded share is bigger? How can you tell?
- Is 1/3 of a giant pancake the same amount as 1/3 of a tiny pancake? Tell a grown-up why.
- Find two same-size things at home, like two slices of bread. Picture one cut into 2 equal shares and one into 4. Which share would you pick if you were very hungry?
Play the Share Showdown game at jugami.com/fractions-shapes/comparing-shares/
Share Showdown game
Each round shows two shapes. The two wholes are always the same size. One share of each is shaded. Is the left share bigger, is the right share bigger, or are they the same size?
Round 1 of 8
Score: 0 of 8
Try the interactive self-guided quiz at jugami.com/fractions-shapes/comparing-shares/
Self-guided quiz: comparing equal shares
Choose one answer for each question. Pick a choice to see a hint about why it is right or what to reread.
Score: 0 of 7 · 0 answered
Sources
We checked the math on this page with these sources.
- California Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (California Department of Education) — grade 1 geometry 1.G.3 (more equal shares create smaller shares), grade 2 geometry 2.G.3 (equal shares of identical wholes need not have the same shape) and grade 3 fractions 3.NF.3d (compare fractions with the same numerator, only for the same whole, using >, = and <).
- Illustrative Mathematics: standard 1.G.A.3 — the grade 1 equal-shares standard, with classroom tasks.
- Illustrative Mathematics: standard 2.G.A.3 — the grade 2 standard on halves, thirds and equal shares that look different.
- Illustrative Mathematics: standard 3.NF.A.3 — the grade 3 standard on comparing fractions by reasoning about their size.
- Wolfram MathWorld: Unit Fraction — a unit fraction has 1 on top, such as 1/2, 1/3 and 1/4.
- MacTutor History of Mathematics (University of St Andrews): Emmy Noether — the mathematician who inspired our teacher Emmy.
Lesson text, drawings, the game and share cards are original Jugami work made for this course. No historical quotations are used. Our teacher Emmy is a friendly character inspired by the mathematician Emmy Noether (1882–1935); she is not a real person speaking.