Unit 1
Fair and Unfair Games
Before you agree to play, ask one question: does everyone have the same chance to win? By the end of this page, you'll know how to check.
Blaise here, your guide. I'm named after the mathematician Blaise Pascal, and his 1654 letters about splitting a game's prize fairly helped start the math of chance.
An unfinished game
Imagine two players who each put money into a pot. They agree that whoever wins a set number of rounds first takes the whole pot. Then the game stops early. Who gets what?
Mathematicians called this the problem of points. Earlier mathematicians, including Pacioli, Tartaglia and Cardano, had already worked on it. In the summer of 1654, Blaise Pascal and Pierre de Fermat, two French mathematicians, traded letters about it and about a puzzle with dice. They solved the problem of points for two players. Their short exchange laid the foundations of probability theory.
To split the pot fairly, you need a way to measure how likely each player was to win. That measuring tool is probability.
How likely is it? The 0 to 1 scale
The probability of an event is a number that tells how likely it is to happen. Every probability is between 0 and 1.
- Impossible (0): it cannot happen.
- Unlikely: between 0 and ½.
- Even chance (½): as likely to happen as not.
- Likely: between ½ and 1.
- Certain (1): it must happen.
A probability can never be less than 0 or more than 1. If you ever get 7/5 or −0.2 as an answer, something went wrong.
Equally likely outcomes
An outcome is one possible result, like rolling a 4. An event is the outcome or group of outcomes you care about, like "rolling an even number."
Outcomes are equally likely when each one has the same chance. A fair coin, a fair six-sided die and a spinner with same-size sections all have equally likely outcomes. When that's true, you can find a probability by counting:
Probability of an event = (number of outcomes in the event) ÷ (total number of equally likely outcomes)
Careful: this counting rule only works when the outcomes really are equally likely. Look at these two spinners.
On the right spinner, "three colors" does not mean "⅓ each." Red covers half the circle, so the probability of red is ½. Always ask: are these outcomes really the same size, the same weight, the same chance?
Worked examples
Example 1: Place it on the scale
Where does each event go? (a) Rolling a 7 on a regular six-sided die. (b) A fair coin landing tails. (c) Pulling a blue marble from a bag that holds only blue marbles.
(a) A die has no 7, so the probability is 0: impossible. (b) Tails is 1 of 2 equally likely outcomes: ½, an even chance. (c) Every marble is blue, so the probability is 1: certain.
Example 2: A spinner with eight sections
The spinner has 8 equal sections: 3 green and 5 gold. What is the probability of landing on green?
The 8 sections are equally likely, and 3 of them are green. Probability of green = 3 ÷ 8 = 3/8 = 0.375. (Gold is 5/8. Check: 3/8 + 5/8 = 1.)
Example 3: One die
You roll a fair six-sided die. What is the probability of rolling a number less than 3?
The outcomes 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 are equally likely. Only 1 and 2 are less than 3. Probability = 2/6 = 1/3, which is unlikely.
Example 4: Twenty coin flips
Maya flips a fair coin 20 times and gets 13 heads. What fraction of her flips were heads? Does this prove the coin is unfair?
13 out of 20 = 13/20 = 0.65. The theoretical probability is ½ = 0.5. No, it doesn't prove anything: 20 flips is a small number, and short runs often wander away from ½. See the next section.
Experimental vs theoretical probability
There are two ways to get a probability:
- Theoretical probability comes from thinking: count the equally likely outcomes. A fair die gives 1/6 for a 6.
- Experimental probability comes from doing: run trials and see what happens. If you roll a 6 eleven times in 60 rolls, the experimental probability is 11/60.
The two usually don't match exactly, and that's normal. Chance is lumpy over a few tries. With many more trials, the experimental probability usually settles close to the theoretical one. Try it in the simulator below: run 10 trials, then 1,000, and watch the gap.
Experiments are also how we find probabilities when we can't count equally likely outcomes, like the chance that a tossed paper cup lands on its side.
Probability simulator
Pick something to roll or spin and an event to watch. Press a button to run trials. The table compares what happened (experimental) with what should happen in the long run (theoretical).
No trials yet.
| Trials | 0 |
|---|---|
| Times the event happened | 0 |
| Experimental probability | – |
| Theoretical probability | – |
Tally of every outcome
Try the interactive simulator and fair-game challenge at jugami.com/chance/fair-and-unfair-games/
Is this game fair?
A game of chance is fair when every player has the same probability of winning. If one player's chance is bigger, the game is unfair, even if the other player still wins sometimes.
To check a game, use three steps:
- List every equally likely outcome.
- Count the outcomes that make each player win.
- Compare. Equal counts mean a fair game.
Step 1 is where people slip. Flip two coins. It's tempting to say there are three outcomes: two heads, two tails, or one of each. But give the coins names, a penny and a dime, and you'll see four equally likely outcomes:
So the probability of two heads is 1/4, and the probability of one head and one tail is 2/4 = 1/2. Two dice work the same way: a red die and a blue die give 6 × 6 = 36 equally likely outcomes.
Challenge: fair or unfair?
Read each game. Decide whether Player A and Player B have the same chance of winning a round. Then press "Test it" to play 1,000 rounds and see if the results agree.
Game 1: Even or odd
Roll one die. Player A wins on an even number. Player B wins on an odd number.
Game 2: Small sums, big sums
Roll two dice and add them. Player A wins if the sum is 2 to 6. Player B wins if the sum is 7 to 12.
Game 3: Match or mix
Flip two coins. Player A wins if they match (both heads or both tails). Player B wins if they are different.
Game 4: The lopsided spinner
Spin this spinner: red is half the circle, blue is a quarter and gold is a quarter. Player A wins on red. Player B wins on blue or gold.
Game 5: Times table
Roll two dice and multiply them. Player A wins if the product is even. Player B wins if the product is odd.
Back to the unfinished game
Now you have the tools to split that pot. Say each player is equally likely to win any round. The game was "first to 3 wins," and it stopped with A ahead 2 to 1.
A needs 1 more win. B needs 2. So at most 2 more rounds would settle it. Picture both of those rounds being played, even if the first one already decides things. That gives 4 equally likely ways to finish:
| Round 4 | Round 5 | Who takes the pot? |
|---|---|---|
| A | A | A |
| A | B | A |
| B | A | A |
| B | B | B |
A wins in 3 of the 4 ways, so A's probability of winning was 3/4 and B's was 1/4. A fair split gives A three parts of the pot for every one part B gets. With 24 coins in the pot, that's 18 for A and 6 for B.
Notice the idea: fairness isn't "split it in half," and it isn't "the leader takes everything." It's "share according to each player's chance." That idea, counting the ways a game could go, is the heart of probability.
Practice problems
- A bag holds 4 red counters and 6 yellow counters, all the same size. You reach in without looking. What is the probability of pulling out a red counter?
- An event has a probability of 0.9. Which word on the scale fits it best?
- A spinner has 5 equal sections numbered 1 to 5. Player A wins on an odd number and Player B wins on an even number. Is the game fair?
Show answers
- 4 of the 10 counters are red: 4/10 = 2/5.
- Likely. 0.9 is between ½ and 1, and close to 1.
- Unfair. The odd numbers are 1, 3 and 5 (3 of 5); the even numbers are 2 and 4 (2 of 5). Player A has the better chance, 3/5 vs 2/5.
Self-guided quiz
Nine questions. Pick an answer and you'll see why it's right or wrong. Press "Check my self-guided quiz" for your score.
Talk about it
- Think of a game you play that uses dice, cards or a spinner. Do you think it's fair? How could you check?
- Sometimes an unfair game is on purpose, like a handicap that helps a younger player. When might an unfair game be a good idea?
- Your friend flips a coin 5 times and gets 5 heads. Is the next flip more likely to be tails? Why or why not?
Sources
- Blaise Pascal biography (letters with Fermat, summer 1654; problem of points), MacTutor, University of St Andrews
- Pierre de Fermat biography (1654 correspondence; joint founders of probability), MacTutor, University of St Andrews
- Outcomes, equally likely events and the 0 to 1 range, OpenStax Introductory Statistics 2e, section 3.1
- Grade 7 Unit 8, Probability and Sampling, Illustrative Mathematics (CC BY 4.0)
Credits: all drawings, games and examples on this page are original work made for Jugami. All drawings are original SVG art made for this course.